When Cherry’s father announces that they are moving in with his girlfriend who lives in Somerset, Cherry doesn’t realise that she is about to get four new sisters. The four girls are Skye, with blue eyes and blond hair, Summer who is slim, determined and graceful, Honey, who is beautiful, blond and willowy and Coco, who is tomboyish, fair and freckled.

The plot in The Chocolate Box Girls: Cherry Crush begins to escalate when Cherry encounters Shay Fletcher, who, according to Cherry, should come with a government warning label because of how handsome he is. Unfortunately for Cherry, her new stepsister, Honey, is Shay’s girlfriend. As Cherry’s attraction for Shay grows, her desire to be near him heightens as well. Cherry knows this could destroy her relationship with her new sisters. She needs to figure out what to do and how to put aside her attraction for Shay.